Your mother paid in for decades. Doggy checked the government bill.

Your mother paid in for decades: state pensions versus asylum accommodation costs

I followed the government spending. In these four examples, the cost of a reception place or asylum hotel is higher than the specified annual pension or old-age allowance. For someone who worked and contributed for decades, then has to stretch a pension across housing, heating and food, that is a comparison worth scrutinising.

The comparison is government expenditure on particular services and pension payments. It is not total government expenditure on either group, nor cash benefits received by asylum seekers. Much reception spending goes to providers. Pensioners may also receive healthcare, housing support, social care and other benefits, which are outside the pension figures here. It would therefore be incorrect to infer that every asylum seeker receives more total public support than every pensioner.

One asylum hotel place costs more than four full UK new State Pensions

The figures used

CountryAnnual reception/accommodation cost benchmarkAnnual pension or allowance benchmarkRatio
Italy: Lodi local tender, 2024€12,096€6,947 old-age social allowance1.74×
Ireland, 2024€30,660€14,420 maximum basic contributory pension, under 802.13×
Netherlands, 2024€50,250 published average reception cost€19,595 full single-person AOW, approximate gross annual entitlement2.56×
UK, June 2026 hotel estimate / 2026–27 pension£52,560£12,548 full new State Pension4.19×

Displayed amounts are rounded. Ratios use the underlying amounts where available. These selected examples are not a harmonised international ranking: the Italian numerator is a local tender benchmark; Ireland and the Netherlands use reception averages; the UK figure concerns hotels specifically. Different systems fund different services within reception costs.

Italy: Lodi reception tender compared with the old-age social allowance

Italy: a local tender, not a national spending average

The Lodi collective reception tender in 2024 specified €30.64 per person per day plus €2.50 daily pocket money. Multiplying €33.14 by 365 gives €12,096.10. This is an annualised tender benchmark, not actual expenditure on every asylum seeker or evidence of a whole-year stay. VAT and separately reimbursed items are not included in that calculation.

INPS gives the 2024 full social allowance as €534.41 for 13 monthly payments, or €6,947.33. The ratio is 1.7418. The allowance is a means-tested old-age safety net, not a pension earned through employment contributions. The Italian example therefore concerns the old-age safety net, rather than the typical pension of a lifelong contributor.

Sources: Lodi Prefecture's 2024 procurement archive, local reporting of the tender rates, INPS 2024 allowance presentation. The tender structure is also documented in this official 2024 collective-reception procurement decision.

Ireland: asylum accommodation costs compared with the basic State Pension

Ireland: accommodation and related services

The parliamentary Public Accounts Committee reports an average €84 per applicant per night in 2024, covering accommodation and related costs including facilities management, transport and utilities. A 365-night equivalent is €30,660. It is not a cash allowance or the cost of someone who stayed for only part of a year.

The maximum basic contributory pension for someone under 80 was €277.30 weekly in 2024. Fifty-two payments give €14,419.60; the ratio is 2.1263. This excludes Christmas bonuses, supplements and other benefits, so it is the recurring basic pension rather than all annual payments or total support.

Sources: Public Accounts Committee report, November 2026, printed page 16, Government Budget 2024 benefit rates.

Netherlands: reception costs compared with full single-person AOW

Netherlands: reception and full single-person AOW

The government's answer to question 37 in the 2024 Justice and Security annual-report scrutiny states an average €50,250 per person per year for regular and emergency reception. The answer concerns recognised refugees still in COA accommodation and uses the reception average to estimate their cost; COA residents include applicants and recognised refugees awaiting housing. I use that published reception average here.

The approximate €19,595 gross AOW benchmark combines six months at each 2024 full single-person rate, including the associated holiday-allowance accrual: 6 × (€1,541.53 + €76.20) + 6 × (€1,569.75 + €78.34) = €19,594.92. This is a rate-based annual entitlement calculation, not an individual's bank receipts; holiday money is paid separately. The ratio is 2.5644. AOW entitlement is principally based on insured residence, not solely employment contributions. Occupational pensions are excluded.

Sources: Dutch government parliamentary answer, question 37, 2024 rate comparison quoting SVB, financial-adviser rate table.

UK: asylum hotel costs compared with the full new State Pension

UK: hotel costs specifically

The Home Office's June 2026 release estimates £144 per person per night in asylum hotels. Multiplying by 365 gives £52,560. It separately gives £23.25 for dispersal accommodation, equivalent to £8,486.25 annually, below the full new State Pension. The hotel contrast must therefore not be generalised to every accommodated asylum seeker. A high provider cost also does not establish luxurious conditions or a cash payment of that amount to a resident.

The full new State Pension in 2026–27 is £241.30 weekly. Fifty-two payments give £12,547.60, producing a hotel-to-pension ratio of 4.1888. Actual pension entitlement varies with a person's record. Pension Credit and other benefits are excluded. The annualised hotel figure is a rate illustration, not a measured average annual stay cost or a lifetime comparison.

Sources: Home Office cost estimates, 30 June 2026, full new State Pension.

A lifetime paying in: Doggy asks what contribution should count for

Doggy's question

Governments should be able to explain these costs and demonstrate value for money. They should also be able to explain how people who contributed through work, taxes and caring responsibilities can afford a decent retirement. Criticising accommodation contracts and pension adequacy is a question of policy priorities; these figures do not show that an asylum resident personally received the provider's fee or that one pensioner's payment was reduced to fund it.

I do the research and make the content. Your support gives me the time to keep going. Buy me a coffee or become a member. Thank you for keeping Doggy on the trail.

Photographs and credits

The finished carousel combines existing photographs with original typography and charts. Photographs illustrate the subject; a pictured person’s circumstances and the specific cost of a pictured facility are not established by these comparisons.

Slide 1: pensioner hands and coins, The Independent / Age UK reporting. Photograph source.

Slide 3: hands and euro coins, Frankfurter Rundschau. Photograph source.

Slide 4: Citywest Hotel, Irish Examiner. Photograph source.

Slide 5: COA Ter Apel project photograph, De Zwarte Hond. Photograph source.

Slide 6: Britannia Hotel, Bournemouth, Sky News. Photograph source.

Slide 2 is an original graphic. Slide 7 uses my supplied Doggy photograph. Photographs have been cropped, graded and combined with fades and typography in the carousel.

View the original seven-slide carousel on Instagram.